To avid readers, picking up a book centered on books is kind of like cutting into a cake (already great) and discovering there’s ice cream inside (even better). For a double serving of literary goodness, check out this list of bibliomysteries.
But wait! What’s a bibliomystery, you ask? The short explanation is that it’s a mystery set in the world of books. Whether the crime involves a rare book, or a book is the primary plot device, or book people—i.e., librarians, collectors, book scholars—feature prominently in the story, a bibliomystery crafts the puzzle around literature. Otto Penzler, founder of Mysterious Press, goes into more detail about this sub-genre
here.
So, picking up where we left off, if you like your books with a side of books, read on for our recommendations.
Asta’s Book by Ruth Rendell
Asta’s Book tells the story of Asta Westerby who, in 1905, turns to journaling to escape her loneliness. In the end, Asta’s diary spans five decades and becomes a literary sensation, but though her published entries are known by many, few are acquainted with the dark tale hidden in their deleted passages. Author Ruth Rendell masterfully crafts a double mystery in which the story is told both through the diary itself and through the voice of Ann, the granddaughter bent on unlocking the diary’s excised secret.
Poison in the Pen by Patricia Wentworth
One of
Patricia Wentworth’s Miss Silver Mysteries,
Poison in the Pen follows the governess turned detective, this time to a small rural village where a series of cruel, anonymous letters has driven a woman to suicide. Miss Silver, masquerading as a tourist, accompanies her friend Frank Abbott of Scotland Yard to the countryside, where they hope to stop the next death before it’s too late.
The Pot Thief Who Studied D. H. Lawrence by J. Michael Orenduff
J. Michael Orenduff’s protagonist, Hubie Schuze, is a pottery geek whose digging for ancient ceramics often gets him mixed up in crimes. In
The Pot Thief Who Studied D. H. Lawrence, Hubie takes on a new client—the great-grandson of a friendly neighbor who, eighty years ago, gave D. H. Lawrence a handcrafted pot as a housewarming gift. Hubie searches the Lawrence ranch for the long-lost vessel, but when a blizzard traps him indoors with a killer, the pot thief must face a mystery so shocking it would make even Lady Chatterley blush!
Bookscout by John Dunning
Joel Beer is
John Dunning’s
Bookscout, scouring bookstores and thrift shops for the twenty-five cent gem that he can resell for $250. But he has his share of competition—including his archrival Popeye Lamonica—and the business isn’t big enough for all of them. Unable to make ends meet, Joel is about to give up when he finds a fifty-cent copy of Walter Behr’s
Something for Nothing, worth $500, easily. But Popeye sees it too, and to get his hands on this treasure, Joel must do whatever it takes—even if it means sacrificing his career.
The Tumbler by Peter Bowen
In
The Tumbler, part of
Peter Bowen’s Montana Mysteries Featuring Gabriel Du Pré, a bullying billionaire catches whiff of a rumor that the long-lost journals of Lewis and Clark are in the possession of Gabriel Du Pré. The fiddle-playing cowboy-slash-detective won’t say whether the gossip is true, but when two of his friends are kidnapped, Du Pré faces a tough decision: hand over the journal or risk his pals’ lives to keep it out of the wrong hands.
McNally’s Alibi by Lawrence Sanders and Vincent Lardo
Lawrence Sanders’s beloved sleuth Archy McNally returns in
McNally’s Alibi, wherein he is hired to retrieve a client’s kiss-and-tell-all diary from her blackmailing ex-lover. But, as the detective discovers, the diary is anything but. Instead, it’s the Holy Grail of lost literature—the original manuscript of Truman Capote’s Answered Prayers. To complicate matters, McNally becomes the prime suspect in a homicide investigation, and in the chaos of the Capote opus, he must write off a killer who’s waiting to close the book on him—permanently.
Veil of Darkness by Gillian White
Writing and witchcraft intertwine in
Gillian White’s
Veil of Darkness. Kirsty takes a job at the Burleston Hotel where she discovers Magdalene, an obscure but utterly compelling book about the life of a passionate, depraved man. Desperate for money for her children, Kirsty convinces two other employees, Avril and Bernadette, to join her in rewriting the volume and publishing it as a new work. Success is in the wings, but is it possible that the malign spirit behind Magdalene is somehow influencing the three women’s actions?
The Missing Chapter by Robert Goldsborough
It’s another mystery for corpulent genius Nero Wolfe and his indefatigable assistant, Archie Goodwin, in
The Missing Chapter by
Robert Goldsborough. A loudmouthed author’s death is ruled a suicide, but his friends say he loved himself far too much to pull the trigger. Wolfe and Goodwin are hired to find the murderer, and their search turns up no dearth of suspects. Now it’s up to the duo to decide which of the author’s associates merely hated him, and which would have been willing to kill.
Book of Shadows opens with the death of two boys in Central Park, whose bodies are found missing their right hands. The explanation for this strange murder lies with Rupert and Rowena Comfort—druids who have lived in the wilds of England for thousands of years as keepers of a religion older than civilization itself. But one day, the book of shadows, a witch’s tome, was stolen from their village, and now the couple will kill to save it, starting with a spell that calls for the blood from two severed hands.
Emily Dickinson Is Dead by Jane Langton
First arson, then murder strikes Emily Dickinson’s hometown of Amherst, Massachusetts, in
Emily Dickinson Is Deadby
Jane Langton. Dickinson scholar Owen Kraznik has just been railroaded into organizing a festival for the hundredth anniversary of the poet’s death when a fire consumes a university dorm, killing two students. Transcendentalist scholar and occasional sleuth Homer Kelly suspects the fire may have been set on purpose, but neither of the victims was the arsonist’s true target . . .
The Salinger Contract by Adam Langer
A novel of literary crimes and misdemeanors,
The Salinger Contract connects some of the world’s most famous authors to a sinister collector in Chicago. Adam Langer, the narrator of this novel by
the author of the same name, is drawn into an uneasy friendship with bestselling thriller writer Conner Joyce, who is having trouble with his next book. When a menacing stranger approaches them with an odd but lucrative proposal, events quickly spiral out of control—and there may be no other escape for the two authors than to write their way out of it.
The Antiquarian by Julián Sánchez
Julián Sánchez crafts a thrilling historical chase in The Antiquarian. Enrique Alonso’s world is turned upside down by a letter from his adoptive father, Barcelona antiquarian Artur, who reveals that he has discovered an ancient manuscript. When Artur is murdered, Enrique deciphers the book for clues and finds that the text holds the key to a closely guarded secret from the Middle Ages. But Enrique is not the only one on the trail, and it becomes a race against time to find a mythical object with the power to transform lives.